Real or Fake? The real ethical dilemma...

This year like always I come to ponder over the question about getting our family a real or fake tree. For the past few years we have been buying a living tree, and then planting it. However here in Florida we have a limited selection of trees that we can plant which resemble Christmas trees. So last year I was enticed when visiting a friend's home of the fresh scent of pine needles filling the home, and it reminded me so much of when we lived in the mountains of Colorado that I went and purchased a real tree for Christmas only a few days before Christmas. I'll admit it was nice and after doing some research I was suprised to learn about the pro's and con's to each.
Real Trees
Pros - They smell like the spirit of the season
Pro - You can support a local charity by purchasing a real tree
Con - They don't last as long
Con - They can be more difficult to set up and take care of
Fake Trees
Pro - Easy to set up and take down
Pro - You don't have to water it
Con - Most fake trees (85%) in the U.S. are imported from China. Almost 10 Million fake trees were sold worldwide in 2003.*
Con As noted in the Washington Post, "On the concrete floors of Zhang's Shuitou Company factory, migrant workers, most earning about $100 a month, squat in front of hissing machinery as they melt chips into moildable plastic..."
Con - Most fake trees contain PVC (polyvinyl chloride).*
Con - The potential for lead poisoning is great enough that fake trees made in China are required by California Prop 65 to have a warning label.*
(*Taken from the American Christmas Tree Association).
I've also learned that going to the local groups selling real Christmas trees are having a harder time this year competing against the big box retailers, so this would be a good opportunity to support a local charity.
It's a hard decision, and with lots of options out there, ultimately like I mentioned there are a lot of pros and cons to each. Whatever you decide to choose this year, I hope your tree brings you much joy and happiness, and helps you to remember the true spirit of the season.



Recent Comments